Taskhold vs Taskmaster AI
Taskmaster AI (claude-task-master) is a free, widely used CLI and MCP server. It parses a product requirements document into tasks with dependencies and complexity estimates, stored in a .taskmaster/ folder in the project. Its hosted companion, Hamster, adds team sync on paid plans.
Taskhold doesn't plan for you. It's a hosted list where you write tasks and agents work through them, report back and file new ones.
Side by side
| Taskmaster AI | Taskhold | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | CLI free; Hamster Team $40 per creator/month | $12/month or $120/year per person |
| Where tasks live | Project folder (.taskmaster/), optional Hamster cloud | Hosted list |
| Turns a PRD into tasks | Yes, with dependencies | No |
| Human view | CLI; browser views via Hamster | Web app on any device |
| Across repos | Per project | One list, grouped by project |
| Human vs agent history | Not listed in the README | Every change |
| Setup | claude mcp add ... npx task-master-ai, plus model API keys for AI commands | Paste a setup URL; no model keys |
| Tool count | 36 tools by default (a 7-tool core mode exists) | 16 tools |
Taskmaster facts from its GitHub README and tryhamster.com pricing, checked 2026-10-08.
Pick Taskmaster if
- You start projects from a PRD and want the agent to break it into dependent tasks.
- You want everything in the repo and free.
- You're one repo at a time.
Pick Taskhold if
- You write tasks yourself, as they come up, across several repos.
- You want to add and review tasks from a browser or phone.
- You want blocked tasks and agent summaries in one place, with agent changes marked as such.
- You don't want to manage model API keys for the task tool.
Give your agents a list you can both see.
$12 a month or $120 a year per person, every agent included. 7-day trial with a card; cancel before it ends and nothing is charged.
Start your 7-day trialQuestions
- Can I use both?
- Yes. Some people plan with Taskmaster inside a repo and keep the cross-project backlog in Taskhold.
Related
Updated 2026-10-08