New: watch your coding agents work, step by step, on a live board. Try the demo, no account

Taskhold vs Taskmaster AI

By Jake Marsh, who builds Taskhold. Updated 2026-10-31. Facts about other tools checked 2026-10-26. 3 min read.

We make Taskhold. Facts about other tools come from their own sites and docs, checked 2026-10-26. Where a tool doesn't describe a feature, we say so rather than saying it lacks it. Something out of date? Email hello@greatwork.company.

Short answer: Taskmaster AI is a free CLI and MCP server that turns a product requirements document into dependent tasks stored in the repo, with 36 tools by default. Taskhold doesn't plan from a PRD. It is a hosted list at $12 a month where agents split your tasks into steps and report progress to a live board you can watch from any device.

Taskmaster AI (claude-task-master) is a free, widely used CLI and MCP server. It parses a product requirements document into tasks with dependencies and complexity estimates, stored in a .taskmaster/ folder in the project. Its hosted companion, Hamster, adds team sync on paid plans.

Taskhold doesn't plan for you. It's a hosted list where you write tasks and agents work through them, report progress to a live board, and file new ones. To turn a spec into tasks by hand or with your agent, see break a spec into agent tasks; agents split each task into steps with taskhold_plan, described in how live progress works; and the roundup puts both next to other options.

Side by side

Side by side. Taskmaster facts from its GitHub README and tryhamster.com pricing, checked 2026-10-26.
ItemTaskmaster AITaskhold
PriceCLI free; Hamster Team $40 per creator/month$12/month or $120/year per person
Where tasks liveProject folder (.taskmaster/), optional Hamster cloudHosted list
Turns a PRD into tasksYes, with dependenciesNo
Human viewCLI; browser views via HamsterWeb app on any device
Across reposPer projectOne list, grouped by project
Human vs agent historyNot listed in the READMEEvery change
Setupclaude mcp add ... npx task-master-ai, plus model API keys for AI commandsPaste a setup URL; no model keys
Progress view for youTask status in the CLI; a live view is not described in the READMELive board with a bar split by step, the agent's current message and an estimate
Agent asks you somethingNot described in the READMEBlocked question on the board; the reply reaches the agent through taskhold_updates
Tool count36 tools by default (about 21,000 tokens); a 7-tool core mode exists24 tools
Tool definitions in contextAbout 21,000 tokens by default, per the READMEAbout 7,600 tokens (8,100 with the server instructions), measured 2026-11-16
Last code change on GitHubChecked 2026-10-26: last push 2026-04-28Changelog updated 2026-10-26

Taskmaster facts from its GitHub README and tryhamster.com pricing, checked 2026-10-26.

When is Taskmaster the better choice?

  • You start projects from a PRD and want the agent to break it into dependent tasks.
  • You want everything in the repo.
  • You're one repo at a time.

When is Taskhold the better choice?

  • You write tasks yourself, as they come up, across several repos.
  • You want to add and review tasks from a browser or phone, and watch an agent's steps fill in while it works.
  • You want blocked tasks and agent summaries in one place, with agent changes marked as such.
  • You don't want to manage model API keys for the task tool.

Moving tasks over

Your agent can move them in one go. Taskmaster keeps its tasks in .taskmaster/tasks/tasks.json, grouped by tag. Moving Taskmaster tasks into Taskhold has a paste-ready prompt that files each open task with taskhold_create and turns its subtasks into steps with taskhold_plan. Dependencies become a line in the description, so set priorities to get the order you want.

Share this page:XLinkedInBlueskyHacker News

Answer your coding agents from anywhere.

$12/month or $120/year after the trial. Card up front. Cancel before day 7 and you pay nothing. Every agent you run is included.

Or connect your agent first, no sign-up: add https://taskhold.com/api/mcp as an MCP server. The first time it uses Taskhold, it gives you the trial link.

Questions

Can I use both?
Yes. Some people plan with Taskmaster inside a repo and keep the cross-project backlog in Taskhold.
How many tokens do Taskhold's tools take?
Taskhold's 24 tool definitions measured about 7,600 tokens on 2026-11-16, plus about 500 for the server instructions, against Taskmaster's stated ~21,000 for its default 36 tools. The method and per-call numbers are on the security page.

Sources

Related

Updated 2026-10-31. Something wrong or out of date? Email hello@greatwork.company.