# Taskhold vs GitHub Issues for agent tasks

> GitHub Issues with the GitHub MCP server is free and sits next to your code. When it makes a good agent board, and when a separate list fits better.

Source: https://taskhold.com/vs/github-issues
Last updated: 2026-10-26

> Short answer: GitHub Issues are free, live next to your code and link to pull requests, and GitHub's MCP server lets agents open, update and close them. Progress inside an issue is checkboxes by convention. Taskhold is a separate list across repos at $12 a month, where agents report steps and progress to a live board and every change is marked human or agent.

GitHub's official MCP server lets agents create, update and close issues, hosted by GitHub or run locally. Issues are free, linked to commits and pull requests, and already where your code lives. Plenty of developers use labels for state and one issue per feature as their agent board. Taskhold is a separate list with a live board of each agent's step-by-step progress. [Linear](https://taskhold.com/vs/linear) is the other tracker people connect agents to, [turning code TODOs into tasks](https://taskhold.com/guides/turn-code-todos-into-tasks) shows how agents file work, and the [roundup](https://taskhold.com/vs/ai-coding-agent-task-managers) covers the rest.

## Side by side

|  | GitHub Issues + MCP | Taskhold |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Price | Free; Team $4/user/month | $12/month or $120/year per person |
| Scope | Per repo (Projects can span repos) | One list, grouped by project |
| Task states | Open/closed plus labels by convention | todo, in progress, blocked (with reason), done |
| Who made a change | The account the token belongs to | Marked human or agent |
| Access the agent needs | OAuth or a personal access token for GitHub | A key that can only touch your task list |
| Progress inside a task | Task-list checkboxes in the issue body or comments, by convention | Steps with a bar, percent or N of M and the agent's current message, updating live |
| Links to PRs and commits | Yes | No |

GitHub facts from github.com/github/github-mcp-server (checked 2026-10-08) and github.com/pricing (checked 2026-10-26).

## When is GitHub Issues the better choice?

- Tasks belong to one repo and should link to PRs.
- Others on the repo should see them.

## When is Taskhold the better choice?

- The tasks are personal, span repos, or aren't code.
- You'd rather not give agents a GitHub token to manage their to-do list.
- You want explicit started, blocked and done states with notes, and agent changes marked as agent changes.

## Moving tasks over

Use the importer: paste a fine-grained token with read access to Issues on the Import page and pick the repositories, or drop the JSON from gh issue list. Comments, labels and sub-issues come over, and each task keeps the issue link. [Moving from GitHub Issues](https://taskhold.com/guides/move-from-github-issues) has the steps.

## FAQ

### Can an agent move a Taskhold task to a GitHub issue?

If it has both MCP servers, yes: it can read the task and create the issue. There's no built-in sync.

## Sources

- [GitHub MCP server](https://github.com/github/github-mcp-server), checked 2026-10-26
- [GitHub pricing](https://github.com/pricing), checked 2026-10-26

## Related

- [Taskhold vs Linear MCP for personal agent tasks](https://taskhold.com/vs/linear.md)
- [Taskhold vs Backlog.md for AI coding agents](https://taskhold.com/vs/backlog-md.md)
- [Turn TODO comments into tasks as your agent works](https://taskhold.com/guides/turn-code-todos-into-tasks.md)
- [Task managers for AI coding agents, compared](https://taskhold.com/vs/ai-coding-agent-task-managers.md)
- [Move TODO.md, GitHub Issues or Linear into Taskhold](https://taskhold.com/guides/import-todo-md-github-issues-linear.md)

## About Taskhold

Taskhold is a hosted task list shared by a person and their AI coding agents over MCP. Agents break tasks into steps and report progress, and the person watches a live board. $12/month or $120/year per person, 7-day trial with a card, no free plan. Made by Great Work LLC.

To try it, add the MCP server https://taskhold.com/api/mcp to your agent. It connects with no sign-up, and the first time the agent uses Taskhold it gives you a link to start the trial.

- Pricing: https://taskhold.com/pricing.md
- Agent index: https://taskhold.com/llms.txt
